Citation: Perry MR, Wyllie S, Prajapati VK, Feldmann J, Sundar S, et al. (2011) Visceral Leishmaniasis and Arsenic: An Ancient Poison Contributing to Antimonial Treatment Failure in the Indian Subcontinent? PLoS Negl Trop Dis 5(9): e1227. doi:10.1371/journal.pntd.0001227
Editor: Philippe Büscher, Institute of Tropical Medicine, Belgium
Published: September 27, 2011
Copyright: © 2011 Perry et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: AHF, MRP and SW are funded by the Wellcome Trust (WT 079838 and 090665). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Antimony and arsenic are elements that have a long history of use as poisons, therapeutic agents, or cosmetics. For over a century, compounds containing pentavalent antimony (antimonials) have formed the basis of treatment of the leishmaniases worldwide. Antimonial preparations remain first-line drugs for visceral leishmaniasis in Sub-Saharan Africa and Brazil , but in the hyperendemic state of Bihar, India, the cure rate of antimonial compounds has declined over the past 30 years from over 85% to less than 50% (Figure 1)  and resistance in parasites has been demonstrated . This marked decrease in efficacy has been attributed to long-term, widespread misuse of antimonials, with patients undergoing inappropriate treatment courses often administered by the largely unregulated Indian private health care system , . Here we propose an additional hypothesis to explain the substantially lower efficacy of antimony in Bihar compared to other regions in the world.
Figure 1. Results of consecutive clinical studies of antimonials at 20 mg/kg dosing in Bihar, India.
Graph drawn from data presented in tabular form in a systematic review of clinical trials done in India between 1980 and 2004 . Doses received are indicated in the figure key. Linear regression correlation coefficient = −0.831.doi:10.1371/journal.pntd.0001227.g001
Since the 1970s, millions of inhabitants of Asia have been chronically exposed to naturally occurring arsenic on a daily basis through the large-scale insertion of multiple shallow tubewells which were originally installed for provision of clean and safe drinking water . Antimony and arsenic are metalloids belonging to Group 15 of the periodic table that share many structural and chemical properties . Antimony resistance in Leishmania parasites can be induced experimentally by exposure to stepwise increasing concentrations of sublethal concentrations of trivalent arsenite in culture . If an individual who is chronically exposed to arsenic is infected with Leishmania, the parasites would be exposed to arsenic due to its presence within organs of the lymphoreticular system . This could lead to the development of an arsenic-resistant Leishmania strain that would be cross-resistant to antimonial therapy. This viewpoint article will expand on, and discuss the evidence for, the possible contribution of arsenic to decreased antimonial efficacy in Bihar.
The Leishmaniases are a group of diseases caused by infection with the protozoan parasite Leishmania, transmitted by the sandfly. The most serious form of the disease is visceral leishmaniasis, which results from infection with Leishmania donovani and Leishmania infantum. The amastigote form replicates in macrophages of the liver, spleen, and bone marrow, causing persistent fever, hepatosplenomegaly, weight loss, and pancytopenia. If untreated it is eventually fatal  and is thought to account for 41,000 deaths per year .
Approximately 60% of the worldwide incidence of visceral leishmaniasis is in the Indian subcontinent , where it has an anthroponotic transmission which follows a cluster pattern. Ninety percent of India's disease burden is thought to occur in Bihar , and in 2009, the incidence was estimated at 22 per 10,000 of the population . Supported by the World Health Organisation, the governments of India, Nepal, and Bangladesh are currently implementing an elimination programme that aims to reduce the incidence of the disease to less than 1 per 10,000 by 2015 .
Resistance and Epidemiology
Visceral leishmaniasis was almost eliminated in India in the 1950s and 1960s as a secondary consequence of the National Malaria Eradication programme. After the programme's termination the sandfly vector population increased, resulting in a resurgence of visceral leishmaniasis reaching epidemic proportions in the late 1970s . Primary unresponsiveness to antimonials became evident during this epidemic when physicians found the prior standard 6-day antimonial regime to be “grossly inadequate” . As a result, a 20-day regime at 10 mg/kg was introduced which was further increased in subsequent years up to 20 mg/kg for 30 days to try to reduce the increasingly high rate of relapse . Despite this, cure rates with antimonial treatment continued to fall . Subsequently, new, effective therapies, such as oral miltefosine and intravenous amphotericin B deoxycholate, have been incorporated into routine clinical practice and now form the treatment backbone of the visceral leishmaniasis elimination programme .
The emergence of decreased antimonial efficacy within the epidemic occurred in the years directly following the large-scale insertion of shallow tubewells across Asia in the early 1970s. The natural occurrence of high levels of arsenic in the groundwater accessed by many of these tubewells was only discovered in Bihar in 2002 , although it is believed to have been present since the tubewells were inserted . This late finding came despite Bihar's close geographic proximity to West Bengal and Bangladesh, where the occurrence of mass arsenic poisoning was identified in the 1980s and 1990s, respectively . By 2007 UNICEF had tested 66,623 tubewells in Bihar and found 28.9% had arsenic levels greater than the WHO standard of 10 µg/L, affecting at least 7.2 million of the population .
The Indian subcontinent is the only place worldwide where endemic visceral leishmaniasis and significant arsenic contamination of the groundwater co-exist , and it is from Bihar and Nepal that the highest rates of antimonial treatment failures are found , . In the map of Bihar in Figure 2, the available information from journals, websites, and published databases on the incidence of visceral leishmaniasis, antimonial resistance, and arsenic contamination of the groundwater has been collated. This epidemiological data must be interpreted in the context of an estimated 73%–90% under-reporting of visceral leishmaniasis  and the incomplete analysis of tubewell water throughout Bihar. However, it does demonstrate 10 endemic VL districts where part of the population's consumption of water from arsenic contaminated tubewells could have resulted in the induction of antimonial resistance of Leishmania parasites through arsenic exposure via their human host. Our hypothesis has parallels with the subtherapeutic exposure of South American, South East Asian, and African populations to chloroquine through medicated salt in the 1950s and 1960s, which is thought to have contributed to the spread of chloroquine resistant malaria .
Figure 2. Map of Bihar showing district distribution of visceral leishmaniasis endemicity, antimonial resistance, and arsenic contamination of the groundwater.
The map is based on published data , , – with additional data from http://www.indiawaterportal.org/node/10925 and http://www.soesju.org/arsenic/groundwater_bihar.htm, both last accessed 12/20/2010. Data for Muzaffarpur are from personal correspondence with Dr. Ashok Ghosh, A.N. College, Patna.doi:10.1371/journal.pntd.0001227.g002
In the northern areas of Bihar there is less reported arsenic contamination of groundwater , but antimonial resistance is still present at high levels. Worker migration between districts is common in Bihar  and dissemination of resistant strains from areas of high level arsenic exposure along the Ganges to the north through clusters of dense visceral leishmaniasis incidence would account for this epidemiological pattern. This is supported by known high rates of transmission , demonstrable superior fitness of clinical resistant strains , and long-term stability of resistant laboratory strains passaged in the absence of metalloid pressure , .
In neighbouring Bangladesh, where minimal antimonial resistance has been reported, high-level arsenic contamination is mainly in the south of the country , whereas visceral leishmaniasis is mainly found in the north . In other endemic countries such as Sudan and Brazil, where there is no reported arsenic contamination of the groundwater, efficacy rates are greater than 95% . In Sudan and Brazil prevalent issues such as intermittent poor drug availability, low treatment compliance, and civil unrest could also have led to inadequate or interrupted treatment courses. The current thinking that drug misuse is solely responsible for the dramatic development of resistance in Bihar does not account for the presence of these same issues in countries where antimonials remain an effective treatment.
Resistance and Biochemistry
Chronic arsenic exposure through drinking water is associated with an increased mortality rate , particularly from cancer, cardiovascular diseases, and infections . Arsenic exists in groundwater as arsenate (AsV) or arsenite (AsIII), which, following ingestion, is metabolised in the liver via a series of reduction and subsequent oxidative methylation steps to methylarsonic acid and dimethylarsinic acid. The majority is excreted in those forms over subsequent days in the urine , but a small proportion accumulates in the skin, hair, and nails  mainly as AsIII and AsV  and, significantly for this hypothesis, in the liver , . There are no data currently available in chronically arsenic exposed humans on arsenic levels in the spleen or bone marrow, the other organs where parasites reside in visceral leishmaniasis.
In the livers of laboratory animals, total arsenic levels (both methylated and inorganic forms) have been shown to be related to dose and duration of exposure. BALB/c mice orally dosed with 150 µg of arsenite for 6 out of 7 days a week for a year show an almost 10-fold increase in total hepatic arsenic from <0.5 mg/kg to ~4.5 mg/kg . Comparable total hepatic arsenic contents, ranging from undetectable levels up to 6 mg/kg, were found in liver biopsies performed on a small cohort of 13 hepatomegalic patients from West Bengal, who had been environmentally exposed to arsenic levels of 220 to 2,000 µg/L for 1 to 20 years .
Should arsenite levels in spleen, bone marrow, and liver macrophages be freely bioavailable and similar to total hepatic arsenic content, then it is theoretically possible that arsenite could kill Leishmania parasites and thus have a protective effect against infection. More likely, however, is that arsenic levels within macrophages of chronically arsenic exposed patients are sublethal, thus creating an environment where resistance can develop. Developing arsenical resistance through selective environmental exposure is a well-researched and established mechanism in microorganisms . Since the incubation period of visceral leishmaniasis ranges from weeks to months , parasites could develop tolerance to arsenite by evolving resistance mechanisms that would also be effective against antimonial compounds when administered as treatment. Although there are no direct reports of uptake of arsenic into macrophages, it is plausible to assume that this does occur because pentavalent antimony is known to be taken up by macrophages  and both trivalent arsenic and antimony have be shown to be taken up, via aquaglyceroporin 9, by undifferentiated human leukaemia cells .
There has been extensive research on the mechanisms by which Leishmania parasites acquire resistance to antimonial preparations . This research initially involved generation of antimonial-resistant strains through stepwise exposure of Leishmania parasites to arsenite in vitro in order to study an arsenite-thiol conjugate transporter PgpA , which was subsequently found to be an important vacuolar sequestration mechanism involved in Leishmania antimonial resistance . Both arsenite and antimony have since been used to select resistance and many common mechanisms have been demonstrated  that have subsequently been identified in antimonial-resistant clinical isolates , .
The full mechanism of action of antimony itself is incompletely understood. It is known to be active in its trivalent form , but is administered as a prodrug in pentavalent form and reduced either in the macrophage, in the amastigote, or both . In a sensitive parasite lineage trivalent forms of arsenic and antimony accumulate within the parasite, but this accumulation is found to be reduced in resistant strains . Both antimony and arsenic in their molecular form as antimonite (Sb(OH)3) and arsenite (As(OH)3) react with sulphydryl groups and are thought to be leishmanicidal through depletion and interference with the parasite's unique thiol system , , which is dependent on the dithiol trypanothione. This system is responsible for maintaining the parasite's redox balance and thus its ability to defend against oxidative stress. In both laboratory and clinical-resistant parasite isolates an increase in protective thiols  and overexpression of associated enzymes has been reported .
Establishing whether arsenic exposure could have contributed to antimonial resistance is a process that will require the integration of epidemiological, clinical, biological, and analytical chemistry data. Due to high levels of treatment failure antimonial compounds are no longer the first-line treatment in Bihar. Thus, assessment of resistance relies on retrospective clinical data or upon the analysis of clinical parasite isolates using in vitro assays. The latter can be an unreliable indication of clinical response  and produce variable results depending on the methods used . Furthermore, if resistance is identified in a Leishmania clinical isolate it is not currently possible to determine whether this is due to prior arsenic or antimonial exposure via the patient or whether this was transmitted from a prior human host. We hope to be able to demonstrate proof of concept in the laboratory using in vitro systems and through exposing L. donovani infected laboratory animals to environmentally relevant levels of arsenic in their drinking water. This laboratory work will help to guide future clinical and epidemiological research.
Biochemical, historical, and geographical data indicate a significant link between arsenic contamination of the groundwater and the development of high levels of resistance to antimonial compounds found in the treatment of visceral leishmaniasis in Bihar. As antimonials are still being used widely elsewhere in the world, continued efforts into gaining full understanding of the reduced efficacy of this drug in Bihar will be beneficial in guiding future drug combination policy and treatment options.
We would like to thank Dr. Adam Polnay, Thomas De Majo, and the anonymous reviewers for useful comments and suggestions.
- 1. Guerin PJ, Olliaro P, Sundar S, Boelaert M, Croft SL, Desjeux P, Wasunna MK, Bryceson AD (2002) Visceral leishmaniasis: current status of control, diagnosis, and treatment, and a proposed research and development agenda. Lancet Infect Dis 2: 494–501.
- 2. Olliaro PL, Guerin PJ, Gerstl S, Haaskjold AA, Rottingen JA, Sundar S (2005) Treatment options for visceral leishmaniasis: a systematic review of clinical studies done in India, 1980-2004. Lancet Infect Dis 5: 763–774.
- 3. Lira R, Sundar S, Makharia A, Kenney R, Gam A, Saraiva E, Sacks D (1999) Evidence that the high incidence of treatment failures in Indian kala-azar is due to the emergence of antimony-resistant strains of Leishmania donovani. J Infect Dis 180: 564–567.
- 4. Croft SL, Sundar S, Fairlamb AH (2006) Drug resistance in Leishmaniasis. Clin Microbiol Rev 19: 111–126.
- 5. Hasker E, Singh SP, Malaviya P, Singh RP, Shankar R, Boelaert M, Sundar S (2010) Management of visceral leishmaniasis in rural primary health care services in Bihar, India. Trop Med Int Health 15: 55–62.
- 6. Ravenscroft P, Brammer H, Richards K (2009) Arsenic pollution: a global synthesis. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons. 588 p.
- 7. Yan S, Jin L, Sun H (2005) 51Sb antimony in medicine. In: Gielen M, Tiekink ERT, editors. Metallotherapeutic drugs & metal-based diagnostic agents, The use of metals in medicine. pp. 441–461.
- 8. Dey S, Papadopoulou B, Haimer A, Roy G, Grondin K, Dou D, Rosen BP, Ouellette M (1994) High level arsenite resistance in Leishmania tarentolae is mediated by an active extrusion system. Mol Biochem Parasitol 67: 49–57.
- 9. Mazumder DNG (2005) Effect of chronic intake of arsenic-contaminated water on liver. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 206: 169–175.
- 10. Herwaldt BL (1999) Leishmaniasis. Lancet 354: 1191–1199.
- 11. Sundar S, Mondal D, Rijal S, Bhattacharya S, Ghalib H, Kroeger A, Boelaert M, Desjeux P, Richter-Airijoki H, Harms G (2008) Implementation research to support the initiative on the elimination of kala azar from Bangladesh, India and Nepal—the challenges for diagnosis and treatment. Trop Med Int Health 13: 2–5.
- 12. Singh RK, Pandey HP, Sundar S (2006) Visceral leishmaniasis (kala-azar): challenges ahead. Indian J Med Res 123: 331–344.
- 13. Mondal D, Singh SP, Kumar N, Joshi A, Sundar S, Das P, Siddhivinayak H, Kroeger A, Boelaert M (2009) Visceral leishmaniasis elimination programme in India, Bangladesh, and Nepal: reshaping the case finding/case management strategy. PLoS Negl Trop Dis 3: e355. doi:10.1371/journal.pntd.0000355.
- 14. Peters W (1981) The treatment of Kala-Azar - new approaches to an old problem. Indian J Med Res 73: 1–18.
- 15. Thakur CP (1984) Epidemiological, clinical and therapeutic features of Bihar kala-azar (including post kala-azar dermal leishmaniasis). Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg 78: 391–398.
- 16. Thakur CP, Kumar M, Kumar P, Mishra BN, Pandey AK (1988) Rationalisation of regimens of treatment of kala-azar with sodium stibogluconate in India: a randomised study. Br Med J (Clin Res Ed) 296: 1557–1561.
- 17. Chakraborti D, Mukherjee SC, Pati S, Sengupta MK, Rahman MM, Chowdhury UK, Lodh D, Chanda CR, Chakraborty AK, Basul GK (2003) Arsenic groundwater contamination in Middle Ganga Plain, Bihar, India: a future danger? Environ Health Perspect 111: 1194–1201.
- 18. Rijal S, Chappuis F, Singh R, Bovier PA, Acharya P, Karki BMS, Das ML, Desjeux P, Loutan L, Koirala S (2003) Treatment of visceral leishmaniasis in south-eastern Nepal: decreasing efficacy of sodium stibogluconate and need for a policy to limit further decline. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg 97: 350–354.
- 19. Mubayi A, Castillo-Chavez C, Chowell G, Kribs-Zaleta C, Siddiqui NA, Kumar N, Das P (2010) Transmission dynamics and underreporting of Kala-azar in the Indian state of Bihar. J Theor Biol 262: 177–185.
- 20. Payne D (1988) Did medicated salt hasten the spread of chloroquine resistance in Plasmodium falciparum. Parasitol Today 4: 112–115.
- 21. Deshingkar P, Kumar S, Chobey HK, Kumar D (2006) The role of migration and remittances in promoting livelihoods in Bihar. London: Overseas Development Institute. 48 p.
- 22. Vanaerschot M, Maes I, Ouakad M, Adaui V, Maes L, De Doncker S, Rijal S, Chappuis F, Dujardin JC, Decuypere S (2010) Linking in vitro and in vivo survival of clinical Leishmania donovani strains. PLoS ONE 5: e12211. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0012211.
- 23. El Fadili K, Messier N, Leprohon P, Roy G, Guimond C, Trudel N, Saravia NG, Pavadopoulou B, Legare D, Ouellette M (2005) Role of the ABC transporter MRPA (PGPA) in antimony resistance in Leishmania infantum axenic and intracellular amastigotes. Antimicrob Agents Chemother 49: 1988–1993.
- 24. Haimeur A, Brochu C, Genest PA, Papadopoulou B, Ouellette M (2000) Amplification of the ABC transporter gene PGPA and increased trypanothione levels in potassium antimonyl tartrate (SbIII) resistant Leishmania tarentolae. Mol Biochem Parasitol 108: 131–135.
- 25. Bern C, Chowdhury R (2006) The epidemiology of visceral leishmaniasis in Bangladesh: prospects for improved control. Indian J Med Res 123: 275–288.
- 26. Argos M, Kalra T, Rathouz PJ, Chen Y, Pierce B, Parvez F, Islam T, Ahmed A, Rakibuz-Zaman M, Hasan R, Sarwar G, Slavkovich V, van Geen A, Graziano J, Ahsan H (2010) Arsenic exposure from drinking water, and all-cause and chronic-disease mortalities in Bangladesh (HEALS): a prospective cohort study. Lancet 376: 252–258.
- 27. Sohel N, Persson LA, Rahman M, Streatfield PK, Yunus M, Ekstrom EC, Vahter M (2009) Arsenic in drinking water and adult mortality a population-based cohort study in rural Bangladesh. Epidemiology 20: 824–830.
- 28. Vahter M (1999) Methylation of inorganic arsenic in different mammalian species and population groups. Sci Prog 82: 69–88.
- 29. Raab A, Feldmann J (2005) Arsenic speciation in hair extracts. Anal Bioanal Chem 381: 332–338.
- 30. Das S, Santra A, Lahiri S, Mazumder DNG (2005) Implications of oxidative stress and hepatic cytokine (TNF-alpha and IL-6) response in the pathogenesis of hepatic collagenesis in chronic arsenic toxicity. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 204: 18–26.
- 31. Mukhopadhyay R, Rosen BP, Pung LT, Silver S (2002) Microbial arsenic: from geocycles to genes and enzymes. FEMS Microbiol Rev 26: 311–325.
- 32. Berman JD, Gallalee JV, Hansen BD (1987) Leishmania mexicana uptake of sodium stibogluconate (pentostam) and pentamidine by parasite and macrophages. Exp Parasitol 64: 127–131.
- 33. Bhattacharjee H, Carbrey J, Rosen BP, Mukhopadhyay R (2004) Drug uptake and pharmacological modulation of drug sensitivity in leukemia by AQP9. Biochem Biophys Res Commun 322: 836–841.
- 34. Dey S, Ouellette M, Lightbody J, Papadopoulou B, Rosen BP (1996) An ATP-dependent As(III)-glutathione transport system in membrane vesicles of Leishmania tarentolae. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 93: 2192–2197.
- 35. Légaré D, Richard D, Mukhopadhyay R, Stierhof YD, Rosen BP, Haimeur A, Papadopoulou B, Ouellette M (2001) The Leishmania ATP-binding cassette protein PGPA is an intracellular metal-thiol transporter ATPase. J Biol Chem 276: 26301–26307.
- 36. Ashutosh , Sundar S, Goyal N (2007) Molecular mechanisms of antimony resistance in Leishmania. J Med Microbiol 56: 143–153.
- 37. Mittal MK, Rai S, Ravinder A, Gupta S, Sundar S, Goyal N (2007) Characterization of natural antimony resistance in Leishmania donovani isolates. Am J Trop Med Hyg 76: 681–688.
- 38. Wyllie S, Cunningham ML, Fairlamb AH (2004) Dual action of antimonial drugs on thiol redox metabolism in the human pathogen Leishmania donovani. J Biol Chem 279: 39925–39932.
- 39. Brochu C, Wang JY, Roy G, Messier N, Wang XY, Saravia NG, Ouellette M (2003) Antimony uptake systems in the protozoan parasite Leishmania and accumulation differences in antimony-resistant parasites. Antimicrob Agents Chemother 47: 3073–3079.
- 40. Wyllie S, Vickers TJ, Fairlamb AH (2008) Roles of trypanothione S-transferase and tryparedoxin peroxidase in resistance to antimonials. Antimicrob Agents Chemother 52: 1359–1365.
- 41. Wyllie S, Mandal G, Singh N, Sundar S, Fairlamb AH, Chatterjee M (2010) Elevated levels of tryparedoxin peroxidase in antimony unresponsive Leishmania donovani field isolates. Mol Biochem Parasitol 173: 162–164.
- 42. Rijal S, Yardley V, Chappuis F, Decuypere S, Khanal B, Singh R, Boelaert M, De DS, Croft S, Dujardin JC (2007) Antimonial treatment of visceral leishmaniasis: are current in vitro susceptibility assays adequate for prognosis of in vivo therapy outcome? Microbes Infect 9: 529–535.
- 43. Seifert K, Escobar P, Croft SL (2010) In vitro activity of anti-leishmanial drugs against Leishmania donovani is host cell dependent. J Antimicrob Chemother 65: 508–511.
- 44. Thakur CP, Narayan S, Ranjan A (2004) Epidemiological, clinical & pharmacological study of antimony-resistant visceral leishmaniasis in Bihar, India. Indian Journal of Medical Research 120: 166–172.
- 45. Sundar S (2001) Drug resistance in Indian visceral leishmaniasis. Trop Med Int Health 6: 849–854.
- 46. Central Ground Water Board (2010) Groundwater quality in shallow aquifers of India. 117 p.